…The irony is that in becoming more “scientific”, CBT becomes less therapeutic. Now, Freud himself liked to be thought of as a scientist (he began his career in neurology, working on the spinal ganglia), but it’s the non-scientific features that make psychoanalysis the more, not the less, powerful.
I’m referring to the therapeutic relationship itself. Although like psychoanalysis largely a talking cure, CBT prefers to set aside the emotions in play between doctor and patient. Psychoanalysis does the reverse. To the annoyance no doubt of many a psychoanalytic patient, the very interaction between the two becomes the subject-matter of the therapy.
The respected therapist and writer Irvin Yalom, among others, argues that depression and associated forms of sadness stem from an inability to make good contact with others. Relationships are fundamental to happiness. And so a science that has the courage to include the doctor’s relationship with the patient within the treatment itself, and to work with it, is a science already modelling the solution it prescribes. What psychoanalysis loses in scientific stature, it gains in humanity.
-
lecorpspropre reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
spreadingdiscord liked this
-
jamandoatmealjumpers liked this
-
jamandoatmealjumpers reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
shvttheefvckuphairyass reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
usedappliances liked this
-
ayvivianchang reblogged this from utterbliss
-
nerdbeauty reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
chalu liked this
-
chalu reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
luvlaura reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
drkathleenyoung reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
intothestrenuousbriefness reblogged this from psychotherapy and added:
Interesting idea. This article argues...while cognitive behavioral therapy has been...
-
xenon37 liked this
-
tokiowie reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
nattynillabean liked this
-
sugar-cane liked this
-
lokiwhatwehavehere liked this
-
sparksofloss liked this
-
sparksofloss reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
didakticodix reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
pythios reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
erinewright reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
wavydavydali reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
veronca liked this
-
idiosyncrasiesunlimited liked this
-
dreamthought liked this
-
entangledspaces liked this
-
alexleong liked this
-
raudhatulkhansa reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
sarra liked this
-
aufwaerts reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
midnight-consumption liked this
-
turnoffdelights liked this
-
apparentlyrandom liked this
-
fullerenes liked this
-
animatedsuspension liked this
-
littlewendycat liked this
-
zeneveryman reblogged this from psychotherapy
-
josephers reblogged this from psychotherapy and added:
interesting recent thought. If placebos work,...trying to denounce it?
-
luchelen liked this
-
amberjax liked this
-
adotlanemf liked this
-
pixilatedgirl liked this
-
drkathleenyoung liked this
-
spoonfulofvigor liked this
-
cleare liked this
-
adahliah reblogged this from psychotherapy
- Show more notes